Why Marketing That Works Often Gets Replaced

Published by

on

Why Marketing That Works Often Gets Replaced

Howdy Friends,

I was sitting here this morning with a cup of coffee thinking about something that rears its head more often than we like to admit. As humans, we tend to want something new. Even when something is working well, we get bored with it. The normal starts to feel stale, and before long we start wondering if it’s time to change things.

I’ve caught myself doing this with ads.

An ad might be producing good results, bringing in leads, doing exactly what we designed it to do. But after it runs for a while it starts to feel old, to me. It feels like we should try something new. So we turn it off and replace it with something different, only to find out that the “new” version doesn’t perform nearly as well.

That realization hit home again recently while I was listening to a podcast by Tim Parkin. Tim coaches marketers on improving their performance and scaling systems, and he said something that seems obvious.

Don’t turn off a working ad.

It sounds almost too simple, but it’s a mistake people make all the time. When something has already proven it can produce results, turning it off just because you want to try something new means replacing something tested with something unknown. We forget that just because we’ve been seeing this ad for months doesn’t mean that the person needing our product or service has. 

Working systems are usually boring.

The ads that consistently produce leads and sales aren’t always flashy. They aren’t always the most creative. Most of the time they’re simply clear, relevant, and repeatable. They show up, they do their job, and they keep doing it day after day.

That’s exactly what a good system is supposed to do.

If you want to experiment with something new, that’s great. Testing new ideas is how you find new angles and new opportunities. But you test those ideas against what’s already working. You don’t shut down a proven system just to see what happens next.

One of the big advantages we have with digital marketing is the ability to run multiple things at the same time. A proven ad can keep doing its job while a new idea gets tested alongside it. If the new version performs better, then you have something worth replacing. If it doesn’t, the system keeps running without disruption.

The mistake happens when we confuse boredom with failure.

Just because something feels familiar doesn’t mean it has stopped working.

If anything, the systems that produce the most consistent results are usually the ones that feel a little boring. They’re predictable. They’re repeatable. They’re optimized for outcomes rather than novelty.

Before you change something in your marketing this week, it might be worth asking yourself one simple question. Are you changing it because it stopped working, or because it simply feels old?

Later, Chad Beachy

The Marketing Blueprint Sign-up

If you enjoyed this newsletter, consider getting it delivered to your inbox weekly.

Leave a Reply